WHY?
WHY?
When I see all the suffering in the world, I don’t see how you can believe in a good God.
John Calvin comments, "There is within the human mind, and indeed by natural instinct, an awareness of divinity. To prevent anyone from taking refuge in the pretence of ignorance, God himself has implanted in all men a certain understanding of his divine nature" (Institutes 1.3.1). The anguished questions which have accompanied the obscenity that was perpetrated in Dunblane illustrate this truth. If God is good and almighty, where was he in Dunblane? And why did he allow it to happen?
I don't want to exploit that terrible event, but to suggest an approach to the questions provoked by the experience of suffering and evil so shockingly illustrated by Dunblane.
Job⤒🔗
Job was a righteous man, a servant of the Lord. He was fabulously wealthy, and well respected in his community. But because Satan did not accept that men and women can serve God because they love and trust him, the Lord gave him permission to test Job. He was tested grievously. Initially he expressed resignation to God's will, but later rejected the misguided explanations and exhortations of his friends and complained: "All was well with me, but he (God) shattered me; he seized me by the neck and crushed me. He has made me his target..." (16:12). After much dispute with and honest complaint to God, his quiet trust was restored and strengthened and he experienced greater blessing than he had previously known.
Mystery←⤒🔗
Towards the end of the book, the Lord responds to Job, but in a surprising way. He does not, for example, challenge Job's claim to be righteous. Indeed he addresses him as "my servant" (42:7). Neither does he answer directly Job's questions regarding his suffering, though we know the reason, for we have the advantage of the narrator's explanation. This detail is important. It reminds us that there are mysteries that we cannot penetrate and should not presume to try to explain. But it also reminds us that, notwithstanding our ignorance, there are reasons known only to God.
The Caring Creator←⤒🔗
The Lord's response consists of a magnificent series of rhetorical questions. He directs Job to consider the creation in all its grandeur and mystery. He asks him if he was involved in the process of creation. He challenges him to identify the storehouses of the snow and hail and to trace the paths of the torrents of rain and the thunderstorms. He enquires whether he knew who fed the ravens, whether he knew when the mountain goats gave birth and whether the wild oxen would serve him (Job 38-39). Job's reply emphasises both his own ignorance and, by implication, the Lord's wisdom, care and power: "I am unworthy — how can I reply to you? ... I spoke once, but have no answer — twice, but I will say no more" (40:4f).
But the Lord was not finished, and focuses Job's attention upon the Behemoth (possibly the hippopotamus) and Leviathan (possibly the crocodile). The language used to describe both of these creatures is poetic, and in the case of leviathan echoes the description of the ancient chaos monster (Lotan) of Canaanite mythology. The formidable Behemoth is not alarmed when the raging Jordan surges against him. Indeed none can capture him by the eyes, or trap him and pierce his nose (Job 40). With respect to the violent and unpredictable Leviathan Job is asked (with mild ridicule): "can you make a pet of him like a bird, or put him on a leash for your girls?" (42:5), and warned that "if you lay a hand on him, you will remember the struggle and never do it again" (41:8). The purpose of this focus is to emphasise the Lord's intimate understanding and government of creation and to indicate the contrast between Job's relationship to the creation and its government, and the Lord's. Further, the deliberate echo of the Canaanite mythology emphasises the Lord's government of all that is unpredictable and apparently senseless. Nothing is beyond the wisdom and government of God, not even unexpected and apparently meaningless suffering.
Humble Trust←⤒🔗
Job's response is again to confess his humble trust in the Lord whom he knows, but whose purposes are beyond him. He acknowledges the Lord's might, wisdom and care (42:2), his own ignorance of much of the Lord's will (42:3), his new (first hand) experience of the Lord's blessing (42:5), and he humbles himself in faith and with a changed understanding (the significance in this context of the verb to repent) of the Lord (42:6). He has learned to trust God with a new confidence and to recognise the reality of mystery in his providence.
Complete Revelation←⤒🔗
Job's trust in God was in response to God's revelation. Our faith is also in response to his self revelation. But we live in the age of God's complete revelation in the person and ministry of Christ, so that in Christ we have the clearest demonstration of his power, wisdom and care. In him we can be assured of the sympathy of the Triune God in all our suffering. The Father knows the cost and pain of, for example, the death of a Son. The Son knows the distress of bereavement and suffering. And the Holy Spirit ministers the Lord's rich comfort to those who are desolate. Similarly, in Christ we have the clearest demonstration that from terrible suffering great blessing can flow, for he is the servant of the Lord who "died for sins once for all, the righteous for the unrighteous, to bring us to God" (1 Peter 3:18).
There is much we do not and cannot know. But we do know him in whom we trust. We also know that he does all things well, for our good and his glory.
Add new comment